Unofficially obsessed with Google.

Google Testimony on Internet in China

2/15/2006 02:44:00 PM
As just announced via the Official Google Blog, VP of Global Communications and Public Affairs at Google, Elliot Schrage, testified before the Committee on International Relations at the House of Representatives this afternoon. The speech is available in full text at the above linked blog post or in a .pdf file (that froze my Firefox browser, ahem). The major issue is the announcement of Google's new to the also available in China.

For an outline of the testimony, read on:

Until now, Google had been providing non-specific Internet service to China, just giving them the services you can get in America from After awhile, China started censoring queries and results, sometimes redirecting Google searches to local Chinese search engines. The censorship significantly slowed the performance of the Google site in China, with the site being far from expedient most of the time and absolutely unreachable 10% of the time.

Political, business, and ethical concerns about Google's accessibility and services in China led to two decision prongs: 1) stay out of China or 2) establish a specific, local presence in China. Google opted for the latter and has now rolled out This decision was guided by Google's traditional operating guidelines and the addition of a new concern:

1) Satisfy users.
2) Expand information access to all.

The added third concern for China and other difficult markets is

3) Respond to local conditions (i.e. editing Google to work with Chinese censorship)

The components of the new part 3 include disclosing points where search results have been omitted, not maintaining personal data (Gmail, Blogger included) on Chinese soil for Chinese users, but still offering to China in addition to the new This keeps the approach honest yet localized.

The major issues that Google grappled with in rolling out were political, business, and ethical as mentioned above:

Political: Google faced the issue of whether or not it would intitiate self-censorship in order to do business in a country that does not hold similar political beliefs with regard to information exchange. Self-censorship is contrary to the political beliefs of the country under which Google operates and contrary to the beliefs of the spirit of the Internet. Recent difficulties with information storing and unapproved information ability in China, though, have made this political issue one that must be dealt with.

Business: Basically Google would lose tremendous market share (Schrage says to nearly zero) if it did not respond with an improved Google China service. This is becaues of the earlier mentioned slowness and redirection that was occuring with in China. The need to satisfy stockholders and to continue to operate competitively in the Asian market means Google must offer a localized Google service to the Chinese.

Ethical: Google mentions that its goal is to provide the greatest access possible to the greatest amount of information in the world. Both self-censoring and refusing to localize affect the fulfillment of that ethical idealism. Schrage states that the decision then had a very strong ethical element, but it was eventually decided that self-censorship would be most in line with the pressing need to satisfy the above business concern.

The rest of the testimony outlines the need for Internet services in China and the world in general. There are 105 million Internet users in China--half of them on broadband and hundreds of millions more using mobile phones with net capabilities. The number of Internet users is projected to jump to 250 million total users in the near future. A survey of Chinese users indicates that Internet usage will "increase political transparency." With this growing market and sub-par performance compared to local Chinese Internet services, Schrage states, "There is no question that, as a matter of business, we want to be active in China. It is a huge rapidly growing and enormously important market, and our key competitors are already there."

Schrage then outlines what it sees for the future of Google in China and Google's services to censoring nations: roll out the localized product, disclose points at which censorship has occurred, and limit the storage of personal information on users. Action by relevant governments should follow. And almost assuredly, backlash from the individual users as well as cultural change over time should have the effect of slowly changing the way in which countries view information storage. Or at least it is hoped as such.


Blogger ddubb said...

You must know that the Chinese propaganda machine will exploit as evidence that Google's values are not inconsistent with Beijing's censorship. This will give the censors legitimacy that they wouldn't otherwise get if Google decided to abstain. This is not a slight and subtle advantage for a regime that was ranked 159th out of 167 countries graded on the World Press Freedom Index, compiled by Reporters Without Borders(1).

In China, leaves it to the government censors to do the censoring. This leaves the opening in people's minds that maybe their government is more repressive than other countries. adds little more than speed to what a state-censored or Baidu can provide. Internet users can now get their oppression served to them faster and more efficiently than with the competition. And when served by a liberalized, free, western corporation based in a democratic nation, acting in accordance with its own freely chosen policies, the nuanced agonizing that led to a tortured decision between two imperfect choices will not register with the chinese citizen end user.

And why not?

BECAUSE HE CAN'T READ GOOGLE'S STATEMENTS ON THE MATTER. For all intents and purposes this controversy doesn't exist. The only reality is that "supposedly" "freer" entities are no more idealistic than anyone else. adds no data that the censors won't allow. adds much legitimacy to the CCP. That's a net loss for freedom. That's doing evil. Eliminating will not increase restrictions on the flow of data into China. It will restrict the perception that the CCP is no less "free" than a western, free-market, non-government corporation.

Google did not chose the lesser of two evils. Google got in bed with the devil and left the bedroom door cracked open for the children to peer inside.

5:00 AM

Anonymous Googlist said...

Thank you for your comments, ddubb. Please note that the post to which they pertain is simply a summary of Google's own testimony. It is neither a statement of political persuasion on this blog's behalf nor a declaration of support for Google's decision.
1:00 PM

Blogger chuushi said...



(株式会社Catch the Web 横山直広)Catch the Web情報販売2.0セミナー
(井上 博隆)ミクぺたPro mixi足あと自動巡回ツール
QUEST PACK 4in1【田郷 勝彦】
((株)e-FLAGS  楠山高広)アドセンスでシステマチックに稼ぐ最速戦略書 AdSense systematic package
亀丸 圭一郎の情報教材
(中村 明義)mixi専用あしあとツール mixiNavi バージョン3.3 - バックグラウンド処理の時刻指定自動実行機能版
物販サイト作成支援ツール ヴァルカン vulcan(三澤 修)

(福永 亜由美/株式会社メガプロモーション)韓国ドラマをもっと楽しみたいあなたへ~4時間55分の音声でハングル脳がみるみる目覚める!!【超らく韓国語マスター術】
(World Wide Vision 株式会社 和氣布由巳)Score Up 1-2-3 for the TOEIC(R) Test
(奥田 俊雄)暗記と理解が同時にできる一石二鳥の文章暗記法Ver2
澤井 大輔 株式会社 OMコンサルティング 社労士試験合格バイブル~超効率的学習法~

(加藤 良一 整形外科)専門家でも簡単になおらない?? やっかいなテニス肘
(久保裕 株式会社ユニネット)あなたもきっと良くなる!アトピー性皮膚炎を自分で改善する5つの法則
(遠藤 岳)ペニスセルフ増大メソッド『エクササイズ・メソッドオール』
(株式会社KABUTO 藤波孝一)【川俣式整体】 椎間板ヘルニア改善法
竹原 秀明 赤ちゃん・子どもがぐっすり眠る魔法の安眠術

(株式会社 Good Appeal)【復縁マニュアル】女性限定!『復活愛の極意!元カレと寄りを戻す方法』

(アリスエオフィス有末 やよい)メールセミナー『30日で!コワイくらいモテる男に生まれ変わる184の魔法!』

(株式会社 Good Appeal)略奪愛の成功法則-彼氏がいる女をゲットする方法

(中 徳治)櫻井秀勲の復縁マニュアル 男性向け限定版

(高崎 明彦)【 復縁 】 大好きなあの人と復縁できる方法


瀬戸口 理蘭 恋ナビ

(ナレッジカレッジ株式会社 町田ゆういち)【FLS】CD

(井上 鈴乃)略奪!彼氏持ちの女性を自分の彼女にする


(大坪 伸)cabapedia(キャバペディア)~狙ったキャバ嬢を1日で落とす方法~

完全無敵のモテ男計画 松尾 愛

(株式会社KABUTO 藤波孝一)女性を一気に盛り上げ、釘付けにする【ネタ100選】

(大山 誠)会話とメールの全文を丸事パクってもてる男になるプログラム【全額返金保証付き】

日経225先物 「マジックキャンドル10」(株式会社DREAM-CATCHER)

北村 浩 日経先物ミニ BTF投資術

(多賀 俊文)FXで勝利へのMT4テンプレート

(株式会社DREAM-CATCHER)日経225先物 「マジックキャンドル10」

(菅原 博之)3連単確率競馬攻略本
8:29 AM

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Manolo Blahnik black fold-over boots
Manolo Blahnik Black Leather Boots
Manolo Blahnik Black Studded Strap Bootie
Giuseppe Zanotti Balmain Multi Buckle Leather Boots
Alexander McQueen Faithful Bootie
10:20 AM

Anonymous comprar un yate said...

A great deal of useful information for me!
5:50 PM

Anonymous said...

Quite worthwhile material, thank you for the post.
1:23 PM


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home